Anothersole Shoes Review: Leather Flats Worth the Hype?

Comfortable shoes are hard to find. Most flats look pretty but hurt your feet by lunchtime. Anothersole promises both style and all day comfort in one pair.

This brand has gained over 232,000 happy customers worldwide. Many wearers call the flats “shoes that feel like walking on a cloud.” But do they live up to the buzz? I tested them myself and read hundreds of customer stories.

This Anothersole shoes review covers fit, materials, pricing, sustainability, and real wearer feedback. You will also find three solid alternatives if Anothersole does not match your needs. Read on to see if these flats deserve a spot in your closet.

In a Nutshell

Here are the key points from this Anothersole review before we dive deeper:

• Comfort wins big: Most buyers report zero break in time and all day wearability, even during 10,000 step days.
• Premium leather build: Anothersole uses LWG certified full grain leather for soft, supple uppers that mold to your foot shape.
• Two main models: The Lucie II offers smooth elegant leather while the Stella features pebbled grain with cotton ribbon laces.
• Price point: Each pair costs around $145, which is mid range for premium leather flats.
• Sustainability focus: The brand uses plant based footbeds, recycled rPET linings, and donates 10% of yearly profit to feed children in need.
• Some downsides exist: A few buyers mention the thin sole, slight sizing issues, and slow refund processing.

These takeaways help you decide quickly. Keep reading for full details on every aspect of the shoe.

What Is Anothersole?

Anothersole is a footwear brand that started in Singapore. The company makes comfortable everyday leather shoes for women. It now ships worldwide and has built a loyal fan base across the US, UK, Australia, and Asia.

The brand focuses on one core idea. Beautiful shoes should also feel amazing on your feet. Most flats sacrifice comfort for looks. Anothersole tries to deliver both at once.

The company uses ergonomic sports footbeds inside dress style shoes. This blend gives you sneaker level support inside a polished leather silhouette. You can wear them to work, weddings, travel, or weekend brunch.

Anothersole also runs a Buy One Feed One program. For every purchase, the brand donates a meal to a child in need. The company gives 10% of yearly profits to support marginalized families. This social mission attracts buyers who care about ethical fashion.

The product line stays small on purpose. The brand focuses on perfecting a few core styles instead of releasing dozens of new shoes each season. The two main bestsellers are the Lucie II and the Stella flats.

Anothersole Lucie II Flats Review

The Lucie II is the brand’s most popular sleek style. It uses smooth Argentinean leather with a soft burnished finish. The silhouette stays low profile with slim laces that tie at the front.

This shoe works well for office settings. The clean design pairs with dress pants, midi skirts, and tailored dresses. Many wearers say they get compliments at work and during travel.

The Lucie II features the same breathable sports footbed as the Stella. Your feet stay cool even on long days. The leather molds to your foot shape after a few wears. Most buyers report no break in time at all.

One reviewer named Andrea wrote, “These shoes are terrific. The leather is soft and supple. It molds to my feet. The simple design looks elegant.” Joyce, who has arthritis and a slight limp, said the laces stop the shoes from slipping off as she walks.

The Lucie II comes in Smooth Black, Smooth Doe, and a few seasonal shades. The shoe runs true to size for most wearers. Some find them slightly large and size down half a size or wear thin socks.

Anothersole Stella Flats Review

The Stella flats offer a more textured look. They use milled bovine leather with a pebbled grain finish. Wide cotton ribbon laces add a soft, romantic touch to the design.

The Stella feels slightly more casual than the Lucie II. It pairs well with jeans, summer dresses, and weekend outfits. The pebbled texture hides scuffs better than smooth leather. This makes the Stella a smart pick for travel or daily commuting.

The footbed inside both models is identical. You get the same arch support and breathable comfort. Stella buyers often praise the cute laces and the pewter, blush, and white color choices.

A customer named Suzanne shared, “I opened the box and got a whiff of fine leather. I know in a month or so these will be completely shaped to my foot and have the comfort of walking barefoot.” She planned to wear them in Japan for 25,000 step days.

Some users mention the sole feels thin compared to chunky sneakers. You feel the ground more. For some, this is a plus because it gives a natural walking feel. Others want more cushion underfoot.

Top 3 Alternatives for Anothersole Shoes

If Anothersole sounds great but you want other options, these three picks offer similar comfort and style. Each one has strong reviews and wide availability on Amazon.

No products found.

The Vionic Klara Ballet Flat gives you podiatrist designed arch support inside a classic ballet shape. It works well for plantar fasciitis and heel pain. The Vionic comes in leather and suede with a modern square toe.

The Clarks Ashland Lane Q is a soft leather slip on loafer. It costs less than Anothersole but still uses real leather uppers. Buyers love the easy slip on style and the wider toe box.

The Skechers Arch Fit sneaker offers maximum cushion and arch support at a budget friendly price. It looks more sporty than Anothersole but wins for long walking days and travel.

Comfort and All Day Wear

Comfort is the main reason people buy Anothersole. The brand built its name on flats that feel good from the first step. Most reviews mention zero break in period.

The secret is the sports footbed inside each pair. Most dress flats use thin cardboard insoles. Anothersole instead uses a contoured foam style footbed similar to athletic shoes. This gives real arch support.

One buyer wore them for a full work day with zero blisters. Another walked 10,000 steps in a single day with no foot pain. These reports come up over and over in the reviews.

The leather upper also adds comfort. Full grain leather softens with wear and shapes to your foot. After two weeks, the shoes feel custom made. You will not get the same molding from synthetic or bonded leather shoes.

The breathable lining keeps your feet cool. Many wearers go sockless or use no show liners. Sweat does not build up the way it does in synthetic shoes. This makes Anothersole a strong pick for summer and hot weather.

People with foot issues like bunions, arthritis, and plantar fasciitis often report relief. The flexible sole lets your foot move naturally. The wide toe box stops pinching at the front.

Materials and Build Quality

Anothersole uses LWG certified full grain leather on every pair. LWG stands for Leather Working Group. This certification means the leather comes from tanneries that meet strict environmental and ethical standards.

The footbeds are plant based rather than petroleum based foam. The linings use recycled rPET made from plastic bottles. These choices reduce the environmental footprint of each shoe.

The build quality earns strong praise in reviews. The stitching is clean and even. The soles bond well to the upper without visible glue. The laces feel sturdy rather than flimsy.

The shoes are also fully flexible. You can fold them flat for packing. They take up almost no space in a suitcase. This makes them ideal for travelers who want one pair that works for every occasion.

One small issue some buyers note is the thin sole. The soles do flex and bend easily, which gives a barefoot like feel. If you want thick cushion underfoot, look at the Skechers Arch Fit instead.

Overall, the materials match the $145 price point. You are paying for real leather, ethical sourcing, and thoughtful construction rather than fast fashion.

Sizing and Fit Guide

Anothersole shoes generally run true to size. Most buyers order their usual US size and get a good fit. The brand offers US sizes 5 through 11 in most styles.

If you are between sizes, the reviews suggest sizing down. Some buyers say the shoes feel slightly large at first. Wearing thin socks or no show liners fixes minor looseness.

The toe box runs wider than typical ballet flats. People with bunions, hammertoes, or wide feet report a comfortable fit. Your toes can spread naturally rather than getting squished.

The laces help with fit issues too. You can tighten or loosen them to dial in the perfect feel. This is a big advantage over slip on flats that have a fixed opening.

Half sizes are available in most styles. Check the brand’s size chart before you order. The chart shows foot length in inches and centimeters for the best match.

Anothersole offers 30 day easy returns for US customers. You can try the shoes at home and send them back if the fit is wrong. Some international buyers report slow refund processing, so check the policy for your country.

Style and Design Options

Anothersole keeps the design simple on purpose. The brand believes classic shapes never go out of style. You get minimal silhouettes without trendy details that age fast.

The Lucie II has a low profile lace up shape. It looks like a refined oxford or derby. The Stella has a similar shape but with wider ribbon laces for a softer look.

Color choices stay neutral and wearable. You can find black, white, doe (light tan), pewter, and blush. Seasonal shades come and go. These neutrals pair with almost any outfit in your closet.

The shoes work for many occasions. You can wear them to:

• Work and office settings
• Weddings and dressy events
• Travel and sightseeing
• Casual brunches and shopping
• Date nights and dinners

One reviewer noted, “Nobody wants to wear sneakers to a wedding. Lucie II is the perfect choice.” The shoes give you a dressy look without sacrificing comfort.

The design is not trendy or bold. If you want statement shoes with logos or unique shapes, look elsewhere. Anothersole is for buyers who value timeless style over fashion forward looks.

Sustainability and Brand Values

Anothersole takes sustainability seriously. The brand uses several eco friendly materials and practices. This sets it apart from fast fashion shoe brands.

The LWG certified leather comes from tanneries with strong environmental standards. These facilities limit water use, chemical waste, and energy consumption. Not many shoe brands meet this standard.

The plant based footbeds replace petroleum foam with renewable materials. The recycled rPET linings turn plastic bottles into shoe parts. Each pair keeps trash out of landfills.

The brand also gives back through its Buy One Feed One program. For every shoe sold, Anothersole funds a meal for a child. The company donates 10% of yearly profits to support families in need.

These values resonate with buyers who care about more than just price. You can feel good about your purchase beyond just owning a nice pair of shoes.

The packaging is also minimal. Boxes use recycled cardboard. The brand avoids excess plastic wrap and filler. Small details like this show the brand walks its talk on sustainability.

Anothersole Pricing and Value

Each pair of Anothersole flats costs around $145. This puts the brand in the mid range premium category. You pay more than mass market flats but less than luxury designer shoes.

For comparison, similar quality leather flats from European brands often cost $200 to $400. Designer flats from Italian houses run $400 to $800. Anothersole gives you premium leather and ethical sourcing at a lower price.

The brand also runs a savings deal. You can save 30% off when you buy a second pair at the same time. This drops the price per shoe significantly if you want two colors.

US shipping is free. Returns are free within 30 days. These perks add real value to the purchase.

The cost per wear math works out well. If you wear the shoes 200 times a year for two years, that is about 36 cents per wear. Compare that to fast fashion flats that fall apart in three months.

Some buyers feel $145 is steep for flats. If budget matters more than premium materials, the Clarks Ashland Lane at half the price might suit you better.

Real Customer Reviews and Feedback

Anothersole has over 733 verified 5 star reviews on its official site. The brand also holds a 4 star rating on Trustpilot with mixed feedback.

Positive reviews mention several themes again and again:

• “Comfortable right out of the box”
• “Feels like walking on a cloud”
• “I get compliments every time I wear them”
• “Survived rainy weather with no damage”
• “Perfect for travel and long walking days”

One buyer named Anayah said, “Comfortable and soft and wearable from day one. Also survived rainy weather. You do feel the ground as it’s a thin sole but I did 10k steps.”

Not all reviews are glowing. Some buyers report:

• Sole feels too thin for long days on hard floors
• Sizing runs slightly large for narrow feet
• International returns can be slow and costly
• Limited color and style choices

A Reddit user said the shoes look nice but felt uncomfortable for them. This shows fit and comfort can vary by foot shape. The 30 day return policy helps protect against a bad fit.

Overall, the positive reviews outweigh the negative ones by a wide margin. Most buyers say they would order again.

Pros and Cons of Anothersole Shoes

Here is a quick summary of the main strengths and weaknesses.

Pros include: premium full grain leather, real arch support inside a flat silhouette, zero break in time for most wearers, ethical and sustainable materials, free US shipping and returns, wide toe box for foot health, and a give back program for kids in need.

Cons include: $145 price point feels high for flats, sole is thinner than chunky sneakers, limited style range with only two main models, international returns can be slow, sizing runs slightly large for some, and color choices stay basic and neutral.

The pros work well for buyers who want long lasting, ethical, comfortable flats. The cons matter most for budget shoppers, narrow feet, or anyone who wants bold trendy designs.

Who Should Buy Anothersole Shoes?

Anothersole flats suit specific types of shoppers best. You will love these shoes if you match these descriptions.

You should buy Anothersole if you walk a lot during the day and need real arch support inside a dressy shoe. The sports footbed makes 10,000 step days possible without foot pain.

You should buy them if you travel often and want one pair that works for many outfits. The flexible soles pack flat in a suitcase. The leather goes from sightseeing to dinner without changing shoes.

You should buy them if you care about ethical and sustainable fashion. The certified leather, plant based footbeds, and feed a child program align with conscious shopping values.

You should skip Anothersole if you want chunky cushioned soles. The thin flexible sole gives a barefoot feel that not everyone loves. Try a Skechers Arch Fit instead.

You should also skip them if your budget caps at $100. The Clarks Ashland Lane offers leather quality at half the price. The Vionic Klara gives medical grade support for similar money.

Final Verdict on Anothersole Shoes

Anothersole shoes deliver on their main promise. You get real all day comfort inside a beautiful leather flat. The brand backs it up with quality materials, ethical sourcing, and strong customer service.

The $145 price tag matches the value you get. Full grain leather, sports footbeds, and free returns justify the cost. Most buyers say the shoes last for years with proper care.

The brand is not perfect. Some shoppers find the soles too thin. Others want more style options. International returns can frustrate buyers outside the US.

For most women who want stylish, comfortable, all day flats, Anothersole earns a strong recommendation. The Lucie II works best for dressy occasions. The Stella suits casual and weekend wear. You can not go wrong with either choice.

Try them for 30 days. If they do not work, send them back. The risk free trial makes it easy to test these popular flats without losing money.

FAQs About Anothersole Shoes

Are Anothersole shoes worth the price?

Yes, most buyers say the $145 price matches the quality. You get full grain leather, real arch support, and ethical sourcing. Cheaper flats rarely match this build quality.

Do Anothersole shoes run true to size?

Most buyers find them true to size. A few report that they run slightly large. If you are between sizes, size down half a size or wear thin no show socks.

Where are Anothersole shoes made?

Anothersole shoes are designed in Singapore and produced in certified factories that use LWG approved leather. The brand discloses its sourcing and ethical practices on its site.

Can you wear Anothersole shoes for plantar fasciitis?

Many buyers with plantar fasciitis report relief with Anothersole. The sports footbed provides arch support that plain ballet flats lack. Still, ask your podiatrist before any major switch.

How long do Anothersole shoes last?

With normal wear, the shoes last two to four years. Full grain leather softens but does not crack. The soles can be replaced by a cobbler if they wear down.

Do Anothersole shoes come in wide widths?

Anothersole only makes standard widths. However, the toe box is wider than typical ballet flats. Many wide foot buyers find the standard width fits them well.

Can you return Anothersole shoes?

Yes, the brand offers a 30 day return policy with free returns for US customers. International returns may cost shipping fees. Always check the policy in your country first.

Are Anothersole shoes good for travel?

Yes, they are excellent for travel. The shoes pack flat, weigh very little, and work for both sightseeing and dinner. Many buyers list travel as their top use case for these flats.